*This post likely contains affiliate links; I may earn a small commission at no cost to you. More info: HCK disclaimer.
Let me start by saying I’ve always had a soft spot for cast iron cookware. It’s classic, it’s versatile, and honestly, it just feels right in the kitchen. So when Smithey sent me a No. 12 cast iron skillet to try out, I couldn’t wait to put it to the test.
Spoiler: I’ve got some thoughts to share – and don’t worry, they’re all my honest opinion.
Jump To Section
The Smithey Cast Iron Skillet: Features
Smithey isn’t your average cast iron brand. Their cookware is beautifully designed, with a polished finish that takes it to another level. Smithey offers a large range of unique cast iron cookware, from skillets to Dutch ovens.
Their products are known for their smooth, polished finish, which sets them apart from other cast iron brands. Here’s what makes it special:
Material: Made from high-quality cast iron. We’re talking excellent heat retention and super even cooking. The smooth, polished surface is not just for show, it makes the skillet less sticky and easier to clean.
Construction: Every skillet is handcrafted and polished to perfection – these are made with love. Forget the rough texture of traditional cast iron; this one’s all about sleekness and style.
Handle: The ergonomic handle is designed to be comfortable and easy to grip. It’s especially useful when you’re dealing with the skillet’s weight (yes, it’s heavy). And I love the logo position.
Versatility: Use it on any cooktop (including induction), toss it in the oven, or fire it up on the grill. From searing a steak to baking cornbread, this skillet does it all.
Maintenance and Warranty: It’s pre-seasoned, so you can start cooking right away. Plus, Smithey backs their cookware with a lifetime warranty, which means they believe in their product – meaning I do too.

The Smithey No 12 Cast Iron Skillet: Specs at a Glance
If you’re into the details, here’s a quick rundown of the specifications for the No. 12 skillet:
- Material: Polished Cast Iron
- Body Thickness: 4.5 mm
- Diameter: 12 inches
- Weight: 7 lbs.
- Stovetop Compatibility: All types of stovetops
- Oven Safe: Yes

Smithey Cast Iron Skillet: Unboxing and First Thoughts
When the Smithey skillet arrived, I felt like a kid opening a gift. It came in a sturdy, beautifully branded box, and the skillet was in perfect condition. The polished surface caught my eye immediately – it’s shiny enough to reflect light, which isn’t something you see every day in cast iron.
Smithey kept the packaging minimal (bonus points for less plastic!) and included a little booklet with care instructions and some recipe ideas.
It was clear right away that this skillet was built to last. My first thought when I picked it up? Wow, this thing is solid. At 7 lbs, it’s not lightweight, but it feels like the kind of pan that gets passed down for generations.

How To Cook On A Smithey Cast Iron Skillet
Cooking on cast iron isn’t hard, but it does come with a few tips and tricks. Here’s how to make the most of your Smithey skillet:
- Preheat Gradually: Place the skillet on medium heat and let it warm up slowly. Cast iron likes to take its time.
- Use Enough Oil or Butter: Coat the surface with a small amount of fat to enhance its non-stick capabilities. The best oils for cast iron have a high smoke point.
- Add Your Ingredients: Once the skillet is hot, add your food. Just don’t overcrowd the pan—give everything room to cook evenly.
- Adjust the Heat: Cast iron holds heat like a pro, so you might need to lower the temperature to avoid burning.
- Cool Down Before Cleaning: After you’re done cooking, let the skillet cool down before you wash it. Hot cast iron and cold water is not a good combo.

What Is Cooking With A Smithey Cast Iron Skillet Like?
I’ve cooked a variety of dishes in my Smithey skillet over the past few weeks, including eggs, steak, and vegetables. The skillet’s heat retention and even heating make it a joy to use. Here are some highlights:
- Eggs: Cast iron and eggs can be tricky, but with Smithey’s polished surface, they slid right out. No sticking, no mess.
- Steak: It seared steak beautifully, giving it that golden crust while keeping the inside juicy. Total restaurant vibes.
- Vegetables: Sautéing veggies was a dream. They cooked evenly, didn’t stick, and kept their flavor.

How to Clean a Smithey Cast Iron Skillet
Cleaning cast iron isn’t as scary as it sounds, but there are a few things to keep in mind:
- Let it Cool: Don’t rinse a hot skillet—it can crack. Let it cool down first.
- Hand Wash Only: Use warm water and a brush or sponge. You can skip the soap and use kosher salt to scrub the pan (or die-hards skip this part: use a bit of mild dishwashing detergent) if necessary.
- Dry Immediately: Wipe it down with a towel and stick it on low heat to dry completely – rust is the enemy here.
- Re-Season: Rub a thin layer of oil onto the surface after cleaning. This keeps it slick and rust-free.

The Pros and Cons
Pros:
- The smooth, polished surface makes cooking and cleaning a breeze.
- Exceptional heat retention and even cooking.
- Works on all cooktops (including induction) and is oven- and grill-safe.
- Ergonomic handle for comfortable use.
- Pre-seasoned and ready to use.
- Lifetime warranty—you can’t beat that!

Cons:
- At 7 lbs, it’s definitely on the heavy side.
- Like all cast iron, it requires regular maintenance to keep it in good shape.
- It’s pricier than standard cast iron skillets, but you’re paying for quality and craftsmanship. I’m happy to invest in something I won’t have to replace in a year or two.

How Does The Smithey Cast Iron Skillet Rate Online?
The Smithey cast iron skillet has received overwhelmingly positive reviews online. With hundreds of reviews, it boasts a high rating, with users praising its smooth surface, even heating, and overall quality.
- Smithey Website: 4.9/5 | 350 reviews
Most reviewers highlight the skillet’s craftsmanship, durability, and excellent cooking performance.

Smithey Cast Iron FAQs
Where Are Smithey Pans Made?
Smithey cookware is proudly made in Charleston, SC, emphasizing American craftsmanship and quality.
How Long Has Smithey Been In Business?
Smithey has been crafting high-quality cast iron cookware since 2015.
What is Smithey’s Lifetime Warranty?
Smithey offers a lifetime warranty against defects in material or workmanship. Register your cookware to be eligible for the warranty.
What Is The Smithey Return Policy?
Smithey offers a 30-day return policy for unused cookware in its original packaging with a receipt or proof of purchase.

Where Can I Buy Smithey Cookware?
Smithey cookware is available on their website and select gourmet kitchenware shops.
Is Smithey Cookware Safe and Non-toxic?
Yes, Smithey cast iron cookware is non-toxic and free from harmful chemicals.
Is Smithey Cookware Dishwasher-safe?
Hard No, don’t even consider it. Hand wash cast iron to maintain its seasoning and prevent rust.
Can Smithey Pans Go In The Oven?
Absolutely, they are oven-safe and perfect for a variety of cooking methods.
Is Smithey Induction Compatible?
Yes, Smithey cast iron cookware is safe to use on all cooktops, including induction.

Is Smithey Cast Iron Cookware Worth Buying?
If you’re looking for high-quality, American-made cast iron cookware, Smithey is an excellent choice. Their skillets are beautifully crafted, versatile, and built to last. The smooth, polished surface sets them apart from other cast iron brands, making cooking and cleaning easier.
You should buy Smithey cookware if:
- You want American-made cookware with superior craftsmanship.
- You want a cast iron piece that’s easy to cook and clean with.
- You’re ready to invest in a piece of cookware that’ll last a lifetime.
- You like the idea of owning a skillet that’s as pretty as it is practical.
You should not buy a Smithey skillet if:
- You find cast iron too heavy for regular use.
- You prefer low-maintenance cookware.
- You could be tempted to toss it in the dishwasher.

Final Thoughts
If you’re looking for a cast iron skillet that’s beautiful, functional, and built to last, Smithey is a fantastic choice. The polished surface makes it stand out from other brands, and it’s versatile enough to handle just about anything.
If you’re ready to invest in a high-quality cast iron skillet, Smithey is the way to go. Hit that add to cart button on the Smithey website to add this beauty to your collection.